Overview of Five Guys Shakes
Five Guys Burgers and Fries sells milkshakes in three fountain cup sizes: small, medium, and large. These shakes are made to order in the shop using a soft-serve mix, and they can be customized with mix-ins such as candy, cookies, and nuts. Because the chain does not list detailed nutrition facts for each size publicly, the exact calories and sugar content can vary by flavor and by location. This guide compares the standard sizes, approximate pricing, typical calories, and ordering considerations so you can choose the right shake for your visit.
Standard Five Guys Shake Sizes
Most U.S. locations use the following size names and approximate cup capacities. Exact ounces can vary slightly by store equipment, and nutritional content depends on the base flavor and any added mix-ins.
Small (about 12 to 16 ounces)
A small shake is often suitable for one person as a snack or side. It typically uses a smaller base volume and is lower in calories than larger sizes. This size is a good choice if you want a light treat alongside a burger or a smaller meal.
Medium (about 20 to 24 ounces)
The medium size is a common choice for a single diner who wants a more filling shake. It offers more scoops of soft-serve and can accommodate one or two mix-ins comfortably. Many guests find this size hits a balance between portion and price.
Large (about 32 ounces or more)
A large shake is designed to share or to satisfy a bigger appetite. It may be close to or exceed 32 ounces once blended, depending on the cup and amount of air incorporated. This size is economical per ounce and suitable for two people to split or for a very hungry individual.
Typical Price and Value Considerations
Prices vary by market and can change periodically, but the relative value across sizes generally holds: larger sizes cost less per ounce than smaller ones. If you are deciding between sizes, consider whether you want to share, how filling you want the shake to be, and whether you plan to add mix-ins, which often carry no extra charge.
| Size | Approximate Cup Capacity | Typical Price Range (U.S.) | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small | 12–16 fl oz | $3.50–$4.50 | One-person snack or light dessert |
| Medium | 20–24 fl oz | $4.50–$5.50 | Single diner who wants a more filling treat |
| Large | 30–40+ fl oz | $6.50–$8.00 | Sharing or a very hearty appetite |
Nutritional and Dietary Context
Five Guys does not publish detailed nutrition charts for each shake size on its website, so calories and sugar can differ by flavor, milk choice (dairy or non-dairy), and mix-ins. In general, vanilla and similar simple flavors are often used as bases for nutrition estimates, while flavors with mix-ins or blended toppings will raise calories and fat content. If you have specific dietary needs, ask crew members for an ingredient list or allergen information at the register.
Customization and Ordering Tips
You can add mix-ins at most locations at no extra charge, though very large quantities of certain items may be limited. Popular choices include candy pieces, chocolate syrup, cookies, and nuts. Because soft-serve texture can change with mix-ins, consider whether you want a smooth shake or one with more body. If you are watching calories, the small size paired with a simple flavor and no mix-ins will typically be the lowest-calorie option.
How Shakes Fit Into a Five Guys Order
Shakes are commonly ordered as a side or dessert to a burger, handroll, or dog. If you are dining in, you can watch the drink station to see the size poured; at counter-service windows, staff will confirm your choice before blending. Takeout orders benefit from selecting a size that matches how many people will share, as large shakes travel well and can be portioned at home.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Are all shake flavors available in every size?
- Do gluten-free or dairy-free options exist?
- Do mix-ins cost extra?
- How can I estimate calories for my shake?
Most flavors are available in small, medium, and large, but seasonal or limited-time flavors may have restrictions. It’s best to confirm availability at your specific location.
Yes, many locations offer non-dairy milks and can prepare shakes to reduce cross-contact, but ingredients and procedures can vary. Ask staff for guidance and mention any allergies clearly.
Typically, mix-ins are included in the price of the shake. Some locations may limit very large amounts or certain items, so use judgment and ask if you are unsure.
Estimate based on base flavor and size: small vanilla shakes are often roughly 300–450 calories, medium 500–700, and large 800+, but adding mix-ins or choosing rich flavors can increase this range.
Making Your Choice
To pick a size, consider who will drink it, how hungry you are, and whether you want leftovers to share. Small shakes work well for a light bite, medium for a satisfying single serving, and large for groups or big appetites. If possible, ask for a sample cup or watch the portion poured so you can judge froth and volume before committing.